THE DETERMINATION DIAGNOSTIC / INDEPENDENT DETERMINATION

You have to make the call.

‍Check the claim first.

Scope a decision →

When a consequential decision depends on results you did not produce, you may be held accountable for relying on them. The board is about to approve. The acquirer is about to close. The executive is about to sign. The Diagnostic independently examines the claim because someone is relying — or is about to rely — on it, and because the obligation to audit a claim cannot be discharged without a standard to audit against. We explain what the evidence supports, what remains uncertain, and what that means for the decision.

THE BOUNDARY

A report can be complete while the decision question remains unanswered.

Existing diligence, audit, financial controls, and technical reviews can be valuable — and may already answer the question. This is not a claim that other providers fail to test evidence or causality. It is a question of assignment: what was each review commissioned to establish, for whom, within what limits, and does its conclusion support the decision now being made?

In performance systems, teams can deliver activities, complete initiatives, report achieved key results, and declare objectives met — without establishing that the intervention caused the result, that the result became a lasting outcome, or that the benefit exceeded the costs and productive capacity consumed. Those are separate claims requiring their own evidence.

The Determination Diagnostic takes one consequential claim and its intended use as the unit of examination. We map relevant existing assurance, identify what it establishes and what remains unresolved, and determine whether the available evidence supports the intended reliance. If existing work already answers the question, we will say so rather than duplicate it.

THE EXAMINATIONS

Agree on the questions—not the
answer.

A consequential claim has to answer key questions before it can carry a decision:

Valuation. What is the claim worth for this decision?

‍Provenance. Where did the claim come from — and does the record show the basis, or only the status?

‍Disclosure. What basis needs to travel, and to whom?
The examination applies these questions within an agreed scope and states, for each, what the evidence supports and what it does not. What is examined at each step, what evidence is required, what a failure looks like, and what the finding becomes are specified in the engagement terms and the Determination Memo.
‍
If a question cannot be answered on the available evidence, the finding says so — and that is a finding, not a failure of the review.
Does the evidence support the relied upon claim — and would it survive scrutiny from someone with no stake in the answer?
THE DETERMINATION

Know what you can stand behind.

You receive a signed Determination Memo explaining what we checked, what we found, and what the evidence can support. The review establishes whether the claim is fit for the decision — not whether it is true in some absolute sense, but whether the evidence can bear the weight of the specific decision being made.
‍
The review may reach one of four findings:

Proceed

The evidence supports the claim being relied on, within the agreed scope and stated limitations.

Proceed with conditions

Reliance on the claim is conditional on specified requirements or closures. The conditions are named, and each is checkable.

Re-underwrite

The claim or business case requires recalculation, reconstruction, or revised assumptions. The claim as stated cannot bear the decision; a restated claim might.

Evidence insufficient

The available evidence cannot establish the claim to the standard the agreed question requires. That does not mean the claim is false. It means the evidence available within the agreed scope does not establish reliance. The finding identifies material gaps and, where it can be specified, what would be required to close them.

The named signer is accountable for the finding. The memo is designed to travel — to the board, the audit committee, the regulator, the acquirer — and the signer's accountability is the reason it can. The client may provide factual corrections and challenge the reasoning; however, the finding is not negotiated to secure approval. The memo includes its question, scope, evidence trail, limitations, and intended reliance context so it can travel without becoming contextless.

The fee is independent of the finding. No verdict is for sale.

ASSURANCE BOUNDARY

A number is not the same as proof
of what caused it.

Financial controls and audits can check important parts of the numbers. But a correct number does not automatically prove that a program caused the change—or that the benefit was greater than the full cost. Correlation is not causation.
‍

THE BOUNDARY OF THE REVIEW

If an assumption is wrong, we say
so. You still decide what to do.

A claim or instrument may not be fit for the purpose it was adopted for — that is a finding about the instrument, not about the people who adopted it.
SCOPE AND FIT

A defined review before you put
your name behind the decision.

Define. Agree the consequential decision, the relied-on claim, the question, the decision owner, the deadline, and the intended use.

‍Establish access. Confirm evidence sources, access rights, reconstructability, and material constraints.

‍Examine. Apply the relevant examinations within the agreed scope and document the limitations.

‍Determine. Deliver the signed finding with verdict, evidence trail, and decision-relevant implications.

‍Timing and fee. The full Determination Diagnostic is fixed-fee after scoping; the expected range is $50,000–$150,000 depending on scope. The target is four weeks from complete evidence access, subject to agreed scope and evidence conditions.

‍The fee is a fraction of the consequence. The cost of a decision made on a claim that cannot bear it — in write-downs, remediation, and the accountability that lands on the person who relied — is orders of magnitude larger. The fee is fixed after scoping and is not contingent on the finding.
‍

Client dependencies and privilege

The client remains responsible for timely access, the accuracy and completeness of information supplied, its strategy, internal approvals, and the ultimate decision. Material gaps and limitations are documented rather than implied away. Inaccessible evidence is never presented as examined.
‍
Where privilege is required — typically for board, audit committee, or regulator-facing work — the review can be structured under counsel, priced and scoped separately before work begins.
‍

THE FOUR PROMISES

1. We work to your decision date, not our calendar.. The access clock, the examination period, and your decision deadline are distinct.

2. Every finding names what it covers — and what it does not.

3. This is for the person whose name goes on the decision.
The named signer is accountable for the finding. The memo is designed to travel — to the board, the audit committee, the regulator, the acquirer — and the signer's accountability is the reason it can.

4. The finding states where the consequence lands and whether the allocation is visible..  Where the authority to act is not held by the party with the incentive to use it, the finding names the gap — and the authority that would close it.

WHAT THIS IS NOT

A scorecard. An OKRs certification. A redesign plan. Coaching. A transformation. Implementation. A follow-on engagement.

The fee is independent of the finding. No favorable conclusion is promised, and none is for sale.

THE GOVERNING PRINCIPLE

You may inherit the claim. You inherit the decision you must answer for.
Check what the evidence can show before you put your name behind it.‍

Decision Evidence. ‍

Independent examination of consequential claims.
For the person who inherits the result, and answers for the decision.
Fitness 
Can the relied-upon claim be substantiated?
Attribution
Do the numbers show the initiative produced the result?
Consequence
Does the evidence justify the decision you will have to defend?
Signed, scoped, and in a form you can rely on.
What you get: what can be proven, what the result means, and the decision that holds.